The Mapkeeper

Image may contain: people sitting, table, drink and indoor

A short story by Kathryn McDonald.

The path up to the window seems longer these days. She is waiting in the alcove wearing the soft blue cardigan that he always loves to see her in and which she always insists is teal. In her lap is the small photo album he brought her on his last visit. It contains holiday snapshots, frozen moments encased in maroon leather. He longs to join her inside but that isn’t possible. The aged care home’s doors remain closed as the country counts the diagnosed cases and watches the spread of Covid-19 closely. It hurts to be outside while she remains inside, within reach but beyond touch. His palms rest on the cold window, willing it to disappear.

Happy to see him she sits straighter in her chair and she smiles. She doesn’t know why he doesn’t come in, but then he does love being outside. Just the other day he stopped his gardening to smile and wave through the kitchen window to show he was still there. Funny things windows; they open you up to the world while sealing you off from it. She absentmindedly flips through the album while she listens to his voice through the phones they both hold. Her eyes drop to a page of photos from their Paris holiday. She looks at the photo of their favourite boulangerie; the baguettes, the pastries, the rows of scrumptiousness in the window, the cobbled street to its door.

I feel the uneven street beneath my feet as I step from the shop. ‘Bye. Merci, bonnejournée.’ We laugh at our stumbling efforts to communicate in French. What must they think of our appalling accents? Our shopping has been successful in spite of the language barrier. We now have in our hands the makings of a picnic lunch. I check my much folded map for directions and we head off on foot in the direction of the Tuileries garden. He may complain about all the walking, but what better way is there to experience a place? As we stroll we point out landmarks and sights which seem particularly French, n’est-ce pas? The tall white buildings, filigree balconies decorated with plants and the occasional pet, and ancient churches tucked in between shops and cafes. Dodging the crowds of people, we weave through the streets, taking the time to soak up the atmosphere of Paris, the bustle, the history, the glamour, the constant activity, sirens and horns.

No photo description available.

He has been observing her lost in her thoughts. She lives so much in the past now, what must she think to see this grey haired old man in front of her? He talks to her of this and that: the cat’s sudden aversion to the rocking chair on the porch, the way performances are being shown for free on YouTube because all the venues are closed, how he’s finally fixed the broken doorbell. Not that there’s much point when he can’t have visitors because of this virus.

‘Is it really bad, this … disease?’ she asks in a moment of increasingly rare lucidity. He’s told her all this before but he tells her again, frustrated but grateful for the interaction.

‘Yes, people die from it. It’s really contagious, that’s why I can’t come in.’

‘Why can’t I come out?’

‘It’s to keep you safe, to keep you from catching it and…,’ he stops. ‘Besides, everything is closed. Cafes, restaurants, even libraries and cinemas. There is nowhere to go.’ His own world has been reduced to this window, their home and the path in-between.

She gestures impatiently then lays her hands back down on her lap. He longs to hold them. His heart aches seeing those long slender fingers lying listlessly on the page. He pictures them tracing flight routes on the old globe. She was always planning their next holiday, talking animatedly about the places they might visit. Unconsciously he reaches out to her.

‘This growing old thing can be hard sometimes,’ he says to her sadly, ‘our adventures are …’ His voice falters. The temperature has dropped and the metallic smell of new rain fills his nostrils. It has started to drizzle, the light rain settling on his face and misting the window. He ignores it. He does not want to break this moment of mediated connection.

Image may contain: sky, night, outdoor, water and nature

He remembers another time they were caught in the rain. They had been riding on the top deck of a cruise boat travelling down the Seine in the dusk as the skies had opened up. Refusing to go inside the cabin, they huddled closer to each other for the illusion of warmth and shelter. Shivering and laughing they had clinked their plastic glasses together as the lights on the Eiffel tower sparkled into life. The rain flowed down their faces and rain drops diluted their French champagne. He remembers feeling her joy when she started singing ‘I love Paris in the springtime’ at the top of her lungs. Overcome with love for her he had kissed her radiant damp face.

‘Can we just go across to the park?’ Her question calls him back to the present.

‘We can’t. Parks are closed too. Besides, it’s raining!’ The rain has become heavier. Raindrops are now splashing on the window ledge. His umbrella is up, shielding his phone, his only way of communicating with her for now.

She sighs. What nonsense, who would close a park?

See the source image

I can’t believe how many people are in the Tuileries Garden. People are walking dogs in themed coats, some more expensive than mine! Men are playing boules, their outbursts of triumph or frustration peppering the air. Children are swinging on the swings or riding painted horses on the carousels that seem to be everywhere in Paris. Young, hopeful actors are rehearsing their lines dramatically between rows of trees. Busy people are using the park as a thoroughfare. Restful people are sitting in the strange green metal sloped chairs, their feet up on the concrete rim of the pond. Some reading, some talking, too many smoking. Statues adorned with pigeons are watching silently from the perimeter. Miraculously we find a pair of vacant chairs at the edge of the pond and settle down to eat our picnic. Do people really find these chairs comfortable? I assemble our baguettes, while he opens the little bottle of Beaujolais and pours it into two glasses. I bite into my baguette, wincing as the crusty bread scratches the inside of my mouth. But oh, the deliciousness of that combination of fresh bread, gruyere and ham in each bite.

We pore over the Louvre guide, preparing for our visit; deciding which artworks can’t be missed, which matter less. The Venus de Milo, the Winged Victory of Samothrace, the Mona Lisa of course, people say she’s tiny you know!

‘We have to have a plan,’ he declares. He doesn’t like to leave things to chance. ‘Did you know that it would take you a month nonstop to see every single piece of art at the Louvre?’ He is proud of his information. I laugh, impressed. He has done his research too.

A gust of wind blows the water across the pond and onto the guide, obscuring the words on the page like the rain on the window obscures his face on the other side as she looks up. Droplets of water meander down the window pane creating winding pathways like the crazy maps they’d forged on their activity trackers wandering the Parisian streets. She had always been the ‘keeper of the map’, endlessly amazing him with her ability to plan their route to incorporate the most obscure of sights. Surprising him with how easily she’d pick up the trail again after stopping for their lunch of soupe à l’oignon or croque monsieur. How she always kept her sense of direction while he was constantly topographically challenged. Being in the northern hemisphere seemed to have disrupted his internal compass somehow. Sadly, these days she can barely even pick up the trail of her thoughts. Now it is his turn to be her compass, to keep her from becoming lost. But with this damned glass between them…

 ‘The whole world is closed, even the Eiffel Tower and the Louvre,’ he continues. He’s sure she doesn’t really believe him. He shows her a picture of the empty steps at Montmartre on his phone through the window. He tells her that the streets here are generally quiet these days too as people stay in their homes. Except for the footpaths. The footpaths are now full of people walking their dogs, just like in Paris. He smiles wryly at the thought.

‘They say the curve is flattening at last, less than 100 new cases in Australia today. I might be able to come in soon.’ He has to believe that it will be soon. Oh God please let it be soon.

A carer comes to take her to lunch. Regretfully, he says goodbye, hand pressed to the wet glass. He touches his fingers to his lips in a salute of love,

‘Au revoir.’

‘A bientôt,’ she responds automatically, wistfully. The carer squeezes her shoulder comfortingly and she is wheeled away. He turns to leave and as he walks away his shoulders slump. His feet drag as heavily as his heart. The gloomy sky reflects his mood. ‘I’m losing her,’ his heart cries. The rain and tears run down his cheeks merging like memories as he heads toward a home that has never felt so empty. Like navigating the cobbled, upside down streets of Paris, this well-worn path now feels strangely unfamiliar. As he walks it alone his steps feel uncertain with his map keeper no longer by his side.

Let’s talk about being uncomfortable

You want to talk about being uncomfortable?

You want to complain that discussions about male harassment and violence against women make you feel uncomfortable and victimised.

These conversations make you uncomfortable?

How about being a sixteen year old girl, in your school uniform heading in to the deli before school and getting whistled at by a random adult male.

That’s uncomfortable.

How about hearing a discussion on the radio where the presenters (male and female) are arguing over whether women can be trusted to carry pepper spray without using it for revenge, without once touching on why a woman would feel the need to carry it.

That’s uncomfortable.

How about being a sixteen year old girl walking in the city and having an older man very clearly look you up and down appreciatively.

That’s uncomfortable.

And how about the fact that after she glares back in justified indignation she then realises that by challenging the rudeness she may have put herself in danger?

That’s not just uncomfortable, that’s frightening.

And how about this for uncomfortable – that she actually doesn’t know what puts her in greater danger; ignoring the wolf whistle, pretending to appreciate the attention or calling it out?

But you feel discomfort at being made to think about the culture of male violence against women that makes my sixteen year old daughter walk around in apprehension?? Yeah let’s talk about that …

As a teenage girl, as a woman, we live with uncomfortable all the time … recurring sexual glances, sexual innuendo, men telling and laughing at sexist jokes in our presence or at our expense, walking down the street and being hyper vigilant and often fearing for our lives … but yes, let’s focus on your discomfort…

 

 

You feel attacked and cry “not me”…

Why do the discussions make you uncomfortable when you argue they don’t apply to you? Is it because you are used to grouping others, but not being “grouped” yourselves? Is it because changing the culture will interfere with your male privilege? Is it because you know you could do more to change the culture?

You feel attacked and cry “not all men” …

Of course it is not all men but it could be any man. As Clementine Ford said we go out of our way to find the good in men we come across each day. We don’t go looking for the monster in men but we are wary that monsters come in the form of ordinary men.

Of course it is not all men but it could be any man…. even the good guys are culpable at times. The sexism and the things which make women uncomfortable still occur, whether it’s the whistle, the sexist joke, the look up and down the mansplaining.

Sure you might be a good guy but if your response to the discussion is becoming defensive then you still don’t get it.

Sure you might be a good guy but if you don’t stand against casual sexism you are condoning all of it.

 

Seeing the sexism my daughters continue to face reinforces that part of my role as a feminist is as a parent preparing them to face that world and challenge those norms.

Watching them experience similar things to what I did thirty years ago with the wisdom that comes from living and learning highlights the battle they still have to fight.

And this is why I am a feminist.

 

 

Note: After preparing my notes for this article I then found Clementine Ford‘s article which brings a more detailed view.

Another article decrying the “monster myth” was written by Tom Meagher, after the murder of his wife, Jill Meagher

ANOTHER NOTE: This blog was written as part of a university assignment which is due tonight (22/8) after which I will be unable to comment or post until after the assignment is marked. If you do comment I will reply as soon as I am able.

Listen, Value, Engage, Learn

As my daughters become increasingly independent my wish for them is that they would be able to participate in society on a level playing field, and to be taken seriously as people with valid contributions to make to their world. I would like that world to be a place where people who disagree with them would engage and debate the issues at stake maturely and sensibly rather than targeting their person, appearance or the gender.

I don’t think we have reached that place yet. The way men engage with women, particularly women who don’t meet their expectations of femininity and compliance, is still of concern. Many men still have the tendency to diminish and minimize female voices, and to ‘pull rank’ based on gender (or gender and age). I don’t expect that women should always be agreed with on the basis of being female, but they shouldn’t be disagreed with on that basis either. I would like my daughters, all of our daughters, to feel free and safe to voice their ideas and opinions, and have people engage in discussion without reverting to ridicule, condescension, or threats.

Biddulph had written an article talking about how he became a feminist. In it he claimed that feminism could be seen merely as “ranty blogs in the ghetto of the lifestyle pages” and went on to argue that the “real work” of women’s liberation happened elsewhere. Edwards took offence at some of his language, in particular the way he characterised women who, like her, wrote columns for the lifestyle pages as being ineffective, and wrote a response in The Canberra Times. In my opinion she had a right to be angry and to feel his language was insulting. While a “rant” might mean complaining or getting something off your chest, “ranty” is more suggestive of hysterical, the kind of language used to classify women as overly emotional and devalue their voices. Following his reference to “ranty blogs” by discussing “the real work” does imply that he believes female columnists are ineffective.

Her anger and opinion were dismissed by Biddulph who stated in his Facebook post that she misunderstood him. He reiterates his views and asserts his superiority by highlighting that he has been a feminist for a lot longer than she has and that he gets published by female editors. He reinforces his earlier language by referring to Edward’s article as a “ranty blog”. At no point in his post does he concede that Edward’s opinions may have merit, or acknowledge that his language could have been offensive.

Somewhat incongruously, he finishes his post by asserting that “we might differ on some of the details, but this is an alliance that has to hold together or we all lose”. (Here, again, the language drifts into paternalistic territory; I can’t help but think that rather than “hold together” this sounds more a demand that young women accept his wisdom and refrain from disagreeing or holding their own views). Yes, feminists need to work together and, as he states, there are different opinions so surely the logical outcome would have been to enter in to dialogue with Edwards. How is posting an attack on another feminist ‘holding together’?

And this is the crux of the situation, if he truly felt that Edward’s had misunderstood he could have seen it as an opportunity to engage in dialogue and build up understanding; to acknowledge her views and to think about how to express his in a clearer, less insensitive way. Instead, he managed to deflect the conversation away from the content of his and Edward’s articles into a battle between (mostly) women and an attack on feminism (or at least feminism not done his way) as people took to the comments section to defend him and criticise her.

 Furthermore, rather than encouraging the participation of women in the public arena, Biddulph’s indignant post serves to discredit and silence Edwards and serve as a warning to any other young feminist who might disagree with him. Sure our young women might have a lot to learn, but they also have a lot to teach us if we’d only engage with them and not embarrass them for participating in the conversation. In his original article, Biddulph asserts, among other things, that “Every girl child needs to be taught to be a feminist, lest she think her ills and fears are her’s alone. Anger and strength come from seeing yourself in a war alongside every other person who cares, against a world, corporation or just culture that patently does not”. I wonder how aligning his followers against a “girl child” who did grow up and learn to be a feminist serves that cause? How does it show her that she is aligned with others against that world that doesn’t care?

Biddulph wrote in his article that “the work [of feminism] goes on” because women are still victims of sexism, rape and incest. I would add that the work also needs to continue until men, even (or perhaps especially) the ones claiming to represent women, learn to listen and value a woman’s opinion, even when that opinion might be disagreeing with their own, without becoming defensive. Allowing and generating the space to hear views from those habitually silenced would be a significant contribution to creating a fair and equal society.

 

Happy Birthday to my daughters

Last week one of my daughters turned 17, in a month the other will turn 16, signalling they are moving yet another step closer to adulthood and a diminishment of my influence over them. They are both passionate, stubborn, wise, moody, loving, creative, silly, funny and wonderful young women who I feel privileged to know and have shared in their upbringing with my husband.

Sometimes I feel like time is running out to help prepare them to face a world full of unlimited wonder and potential frustrations, difficulties and of course dangers. It saddens me that some of those frustrations and dangers will come about purely because they are female. They will have to work harder to advance in their careers compared to male colleagues. They will be judged harsher because they are female; a mistake they make will be a sign that they (and their gender) are unfit for the role, rather than just a learning opportunity. They will be made to feel uncomfortable when they are out in public; being subjects of male gaze, hearing sexist jokes and unwanted innuendo, being mansplained to or having their words or ideas being repeated by a man and thus having credit taken from them. And of course there is the fact that they will also be potential targets of sexual assault.

When I ponder the message I would like to pass on to them these elements of society force me to tell them: Be careful where you walk, how you dress, who you talk to, but also who you ignore, it might kill you. Be careful what you post, it could ruin your life.

The list of restrictions could go on ad infinitum!

However, what I really want to say is:

Be yourself, embrace who you are and who you will become. Be kind but also be strong, stand up for what you believe in, but also listen and be open to learning. Acknowledge when you’ve been wrong and make amends if needed.  You have every right to take up space in this world so don’t let your voice be silenced or shrink yourself to fit another’s expectations. You have the potential to make the world a better place. Always remember that and grow, don’t let the world diminish you or dull your fire.  Be you in all your magnificence and uniqueness.